Paws and Reflect: A Deep Dive into the World of Cat Litters

Paws and Reflect: A Deep Dive into the World of Cat Litters

To be honest, cleaning up litter isn't a task that anyone enjoys. But for us cats-worshippers, it’s a part of our daily routine. Most cat litter comes with a specific set of challenges. Non-firm clumping, highly trackable, dusty, tough on paws, and not of my cat’s taste are some of the main challenges we face with these litter sands.

In this guide, we will delve into the details of various cat litter types. We'll investigate their composition, how effectively they clump (or fail to!), their tracking behaviors, and crucially, most cat's opinions of them. We will also take into account the environmental effects and any possible health issues. So, put down your scoop and let’s plunge into the intriguing realm of cat litter!

1. Bentonite Sand Litter: Most Popular, Old Faithful (But Is It Really?)

  • What it's made of: Bentonite clay, a naturally occurring absorbent clay mineral.
  • Clumping Abilities: Typically excellent clumping, forming solid clumps that are easy to scoop. This is a major reason for its popularity.
  • Tracking Performance: This litter tracks quite a bit, especially the brands with finer granules. It can also stick to paws and get scattered around the litter box area.
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: Generally very high. Its sand-like texture is instinctively appealing to cats and mimics natural substrates.
  • Environmental Friendliness: Poor. Bentonite clay is mined, a process that can be environmentally damaging. It's not biodegradable or renewable, ending up in landfills.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: It is extremely dusty and may cause respiratory irritation for sensitive cats, especially those with asthma. Some cats might ingest litter while grooming. If consumed in medium to large quantities, the litter could cause intestinal blockages.
  • Humans: The dust can also be a respiratory irritant for humans, particularly during pouring and scooping. Some studies have raised concerns about bentonite dust containing crystalline silica, a known carcinogen upon prolonged inhalation. While the risk from cat litter is still being studied upon, we still recommend avoiding them altogether.

2. Wood Litter: Nature's Choice with a Fresh Scent

  • What it's made of: Wood shavings, sawdust, or wood pellets, often from pine, or cedar.
  • Clumping Abilities: Varies depending on the type and processing. Most pelleted wood litter don’t, clump and are designed to be used with a sifting litterbox. Some sawdust and shaving-based litters (e.g. - Some Okocat litter variants) are designed to clump.
  • Tracking Performance: Pelleted wood litter tracks less than finer litter. Sawdust and shavings can still track, though generally less than clay.
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: Moderate to high. Some cats may readily accept finely textured variants. For wood pallet litter, there is generally a learning curve as they don’t feel comfortable with how pallets feel on their paws (when compared to sand).
  • Environmental Friendliness: Generally good. Made from renewable resources, especially if sourced sustainably. Many wood litters are flushable, biodegradable and compostable (check manufacturer instructions, avoid composting used litter if your cat has parasites). Recycled wood options are even better.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: Lower dust levels compared to clay, making it a better option for cats with respiratory sensitivities. Look for heat-treated or kiln-dried options to avoid litter with strong scents. Since these are light-weight litter, they may track a lot (especially the finely textured clumping variants)
  • Humans: Vary low risk. Lower dust, Flushable biodegradable and compostable.

3. Corn and Cassava Litters: Plant-Powered and Promising

  • What it's made of: Dried corn kernels or cassava root. Agricultural by-products that would otherwise be waste.
  • Clumping Abilities: Fast and excellent clumping, same as bentonite clay. It forms solid and scoopable clumps.
  • Tracking Performance: Generally low to moderate tracking. Larger granules track less, while finer ground variants (e.g. Sustainable yours - Classic version) can track a lot.
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: High. The natural scent and texture are often well-received by cats. Most of these litter comes with unscented versions.
  • Environmental Friendliness: Excellent. These litters are made from agricultural waste. They are often flushable and biodegradable.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: Almost no dust, good for respiratory health. Generally considered safe even if ingested by the cat.
  • Humans: No effect. Flushable and biodegradable while reducing agricultural waste. What more can we ask for!

4. Pea Starch Litter: A Newer, Sustainable Contender

  • What it's made of: Pea starch, a by-product of pea processing.
  • Clumping Abilities: Excellent clumping, comparable with clay and corn/cassava litters.
  • Tracking Performance: Low tracking. Pea starch litters are typically cylindrical and less likely to stick to paws and fur.
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: High. The texture is generally appealing, and it's often low-odor, which cats appreciate.
  • Environmental Friendliness: Excellent. It is a renewable resource and a by-product, making it very sustainable. It is often flushable, biodegradable and compostable.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: Very low dust even after weeks of use. Excellent for respiratory health. Considered very safe and gentle.
  • Humans: Flushable and biodegradable while reducing agricultural waste. What more can we ask for!

5. Tofu Litter: Bean-Based and Surprisingly Effective

  • What it's made of: Soybean fiber, another agricultural by-product from tofu production. Often comes in pellet form.
  • Clumping Abilities: Excellent clumping, despite being pellets. Tofu litter pellets dissolve and clump when wet, forming solid, scoopable clumps.
  • Tracking Performance: Low tracking. Pellet form is less prone to sticking to paws resulting in litter free bedroom and countertops!
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: Moderate to high. Pellet form might be a slight adjustment for some cats used to finer litters, but most cats adapt well.
  • Environmental Friendliness: Excellent. Soybean fiber is a renewable resource and a by-product. Tofu litter is biodegradable and compostable.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: Low dust, Safe.
  • Humans: Low dust, biodegradable and compostable, environmentally friendly.

6. Silica Crystals Litter: The Dehydrating Dynamo

  • What it's made of: Silicon dioxide, processed into small, porous crystals.
  • Clumping Abilities: Doesn't clump in the traditional sense. Instead, silica crystals are highly absorbent and dehydrate waste, trapping odors inside the crystals. Urine is absorbed, and solid waste needs to be scooped. In highly humid conditions, the litter may last less as it tends to absorb surrounding moisture as well.
  • Tracking Performance: It tracks fairly (smaller crystals). Many silica litters have larger crystals which reduces tracking compared to finer litters.
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: Low to Moderate. Some cats are put off by the larger crystal texture Compared to sand or sand-like litters, it is less instinctively appealing texturally.
  • Environmental Friendliness: Poor. The manufacturing process is energy-intensive. Silica crystals are not biodegradable. While they last longer (reducing the frequency of full litter changes), they still end up in landfills.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: Concerns have been raised about a potential link between silica dust and feline silicosis (lung disease) with prolonged inhalation of very fine silica dust, but this is considered a low risk with typical cat litter use and modern crystal litter formulations..
  • Humans: Very low dust, minimal respiratory irritation. Some individuals might be sensitive to the chemical processing involved in making silica crystals.

7. Paper Litter: Recycled and Responsible

  • What it's made of: Recycled paper products like newspaper or cardboard. Comes in pellet, shredded, or crumbly form.
  • Clumping Abilities: Depend on the litter variant. Some paper litters are designed to clump, while others are non-clumping. However, clumps from the clumping paper litter variants are not very firm and often break while scooping.
  • Tracking Performance: Decent, especially pelleted paper litter. Other variants can track slightly more.
  • Cat's Likelihood of Accepting the Litter: Moderate. Texture and feel are very different from sand or clay. Most cats may need a gradual transition.
  • Environmental Friendliness: Excellent. The litter is made from paper waste. It is often flushable, biodegradable and compostable.
  • Litter's Health Effect on Cats and Humans:
  • Cats: Great.  Soft texture can be comfortable for cats with sensitive paws. Some paper litters might contain inks (considered non-toxic) from recycled paper.
  • Humans: Low risk, Flushable, recycled and biodegradable, very environmentally friendly.

Litter Showdown: A Quick Comparison Table

To help you visualize the pros and cons, here's a handy table comparing the litters across our key parameters:

Choosing the Purr-fect Litter for You (and Your Cat!)

Ultimately, it comes down to your priorities and your cat's mood:) However, while finalizing a litter, consider these questions:

  • Is environmental impact important to you? Opt for wood, corn/cassava, pea starch, tofu, or paper litter.
  • Does you/your cat have respiratory sensitivities? Check-out\low-dust options like wood, corn/cassava and  pea starch.
  • Are you looking for maximum odor control and easy scooping? Clumping litters like bentonite, corn/cassava and pea starch excel here.
  • Is tracking a major concern in your home? Pelleted litters (wood, pea starch, tofu) and larger granule options (pea starch, some silica crystals) are your best bet.
  • Is your cat picky? You might need to experiment! Start with litters that mimic sand or clay texture (bentonite, corn/cassava) if your cat is used to those. Introduce new litters gradually by mixing 25% new litter with the old ones.

No matter which litter you choose, scoop regularly(atleast twice a day), maintain a clean litter box, and observe your cat's behavior. Happy scooping, and here's to happy cats!

Page created using Blog & Page Builder by Reputon

Back to blog

Leave a comment